When Lindsay joins Pony Club with Midnight, a whole new world is opened up. But is ​Midnight already too old? After a bad trailering experience, Lindsay’s dad thinks Midnight should be retired and Lindsay should move on to Moon. Will Lindsay be able to handle such a high spirited, defiant horse? Lindsay’s friend, Penny, now has her young filly home and Midnight can’t take his eyes off of her—could it be love? Cheyenne gets into trouble and finds herself fighting for her life. Then, when Lisa insists that Jeffrey and Beau need a horse of their own, a search for the perfect horse ends unexpectedly.  Can the Wrights make the best out of a bad situation?  After Jeffrey is signed up for football, he’s faced with a struggle to lose ten pounds to make weight.  When Lindsay and Beau are home alone, Beau is injured!  Is Lindsay to blame?  In the end, a twist of fate changes everything for Lindsay.